A debt management plan helps you repay your full balance, possibly at a lower interest rate. Debt settlement tries to get the companies you owe to accept less than the full balance. ClearOne Advantage is a debt settlement company and doesn’t offer DMPs, so here’s a look at how the two compare and when each one may make sense.
Debt Management vs. Debt Settlement at a Glance
| Debt management plan | Debt settlement | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | A repayment plan that may lower your interest rates while you pay off your full balance. | A program that works with the companies you owe to try to get them to accept less than the full balance. |
| How it works | A credit counselor reviews your budget, and the agency asks the companies you owe to lower your rates or waive fees. You make one monthly payment to the agency, which pays them for you. You’ll usually need to close the credit cards on the plan. | You make one monthly plan payment into a dedicated account in your name. Once there’s enough saved, ClearOne Advantage works with each company you owe to try to settle for less than the full balance. You approve every settlement before it’s paid. |
| Who runs it | A credit counseling agency, usually a nonprofit | A debt settlement company, like ClearOne Advantage |
| What you pay back | Your full balance, possibly with less going to interest and fees | Less than the full balance on settled accounts, if creditors agree |
| Your monthly payment | One payment to the agency, which pays each company you owe | One monthly plan payment into a dedicated, FDIC-insured savings account in your name. |
| How long it takes | Three to five years | Depends on how much you owe, how much you can set aside each month, and how quickly the companies you owe agree to settle. |
| Fees | A setup fee (up to $99, often less) and a monthly fee (often $20 to $50), according to Experian. Nonprofit agencies must keep fees reasonable and waive them if you can’t afford to pay. | No upfront fees. Our fee is earned only after a settlement is reached, you approve it, and at least one payment is made. |
| Credit score impact | Closing your cards can lower your score at first, and lenders may see a note that you’re on a plan. | Negative impact on your credit score |
| Best for | Steady income, mostly credit card debt, and you can afford to repay the full balance with a lower rate or waived fees. | You’ve had a hardship, like lost hours or medical bills, and repaying in full isn’t realistic. You can still make a monthly plan payment and have $10,000+ in unsecured debt. |
| Risks | Missing a payment can cancel your plan and bring back your original rates and fees. Creditors don’t have to agree to lower your rates. | The companies you owe may keep trying to collect, and some may sue. Interest and fees can keep adding up until an account is settled. Creditors don’t have to accept an offer, forgiven debt may be taxable, and not everyone completes the program. |
When to Consider Debt Management
Your balances barely move, even though you pay every month
When much of each payment goes to interest, it can feel like you’re getting nowhere. If your creditors agree to lower your rates, more of each payment goes toward the balance itself. That’s the minimum payment trap a DMP is designed to address.
You can afford to repay the full balance with better terms
A DMP doesn’t lower what you owe, but it can change the terms you repay it on. Your creditors may agree to lower your interest rates or waive late fees, so more of each payment goes toward your balance. It works best if you have steady income and can keep up with that one monthly payment for three to five years.
You’re juggling several credit card bills
On a DMP, you make one payment to a credit counseling agency, and it pays each company you owe. That’s one due date to track instead of several. Most plans cover credit cards, and some also include medical bills or personal loans if the lender agrees.
You’d rather not take out a new loan
A DMP doesn’t require borrowing money or a minimum credit score. It can be an option if you don’t qualify for a debt consolidation loan, or you’d rather not take one on.
You want a smaller effect on your credit than other options
Closing your cards can lower your score at first, and lenders may see a note that you’re on a plan. Still, a DMP usually affects your credit less than debt settlement or bankruptcy, according to Experian.
You’d like help building a budget
A credit counselor reviews your income and bills with you and helps you build a budget you can stick to. Many agencies also offer money management classes.
A debt management plan may not be the right fit if:
- Your payments are already more than your budget can handle. A DMP may not lower them enough to help.
- You can’t repay the full balance, even at a lower interest rate.
- You don’t want to close your credit cards. Most DMPs require closing the cards on the plan.
When to Consider Debt Settlement
Debt settlement is built for people who can’t realistically repay everything they owe. It may be worth considering if:
You’re falling behind, and a full-balance plan isn’t realistic
A job loss, medical bills, or another change in your life can make it impossible to keep up. If paying back your full balance isn’t realistic, debt settlement takes a different approach. It aims to get the companies you owe to accept less than the full balance.
Most of your income already goes to debt
When your debt-to-income ratio (how much of your monthly income goes to debt payments) is high, there’s little left over to make progress. A lower interest rate may not change much. Settlement focuses on the balance instead.
A DMP payment would still be more than you can afford
A DMP repays your full balance over three to five years. If that monthly payment doesn’t fit your budget, debt settlement may be worth a look.
You have at least $10,000 in unsecured debt
To work with ClearOne Advantage, you’ll need at least $10,000 in unsecured debt (debt that isn’t backed by something like a house or car), such as credit cards or personal loans.
You’d rather try to settle for less than repay in full
ClearOne Advantage works directly with each company you owe to try to settle your accounts for less than the full balance, instead of asking for a lower interest rate. Companies don’t have to accept an offer, and you approve every settlement before it’s paid.
You’ve weighed the tradeoffs
Debt settlement will have a negative impact on your credit score. The companies you owe may keep trying to collect while your accounts are being resolved, and some may sue. Forgiven debt may also count as taxable income, according to the IRS. Settlement may make sense if, knowing those risks, it’s still a more realistic path than repaying in full.
Debt settlement may not be the right fit if:
- You can afford to repay your full balance, especially with a lower interest rate.
- You’re planning to apply for a mortgage or other loan soon. Debt settlement will have a negative impact on your credit score, which can make it harder to qualify or get a good rate.
- Most of what you owe is a mortgage, car loan, or other secured debt.
Pros and Cons of Debt Management
Pros of a DMP
One monthly payment. You pay the agency once a month, and it pays each company you owe.
Possibly lower interest rates. The companies you owe may agree to lower your rates, so more of each payment goes toward your balance.
Possible fee waivers. Some creditors may agree to waive late fees and other charges.
Possible relief from collection calls. Some creditors may agree to stop collection efforts while you’re on the plan.
No new loan. You don’t borrow money to join, and you don’t need a minimum credit score.
Usually no tax impact. You repay the full balance, so there’s no forgiven debt to report as income.
Downsides of a DMP
You repay the full balance. A DMP may lower your interest, but not what you owe. You’ll need room in your budget for the payment for three to five years.
Fees. Most agencies charge a setup fee and a monthly fee.
Your cards may get closed. You’ll usually need to close the cards on the plan and may not be able to open new credit until you finish.
Your credit score may drop at first. Closing cards raises your credit utilization (how much of your available credit you’re using), and lenders may see a note that you’re on a plan.
Little room for missed payments. Missing a payment can get your plan canceled, and your original rates and fees will likely come back.
Creditors don’t have to agree. Some may not lower your rate or waive fees.
Pros and Cons of Debt Settlement
Pros of Debt Settlement
You may pay back less than you owe. The companies you owe may agree to settle for less than the full balance. A DMP, by comparison, may only lower the interest.
One monthly plan payment. You make one deposit a month into a dedicated account in your name.
No new loan. Unlike a debt consolidation loan, you don’t need to qualify for a loan to get started.
An alternative to bankruptcy. For some people, it’s a way to deal with debt they can’t repay without filing for bankruptcy.
No upfront fees with ClearOne Advantage. You approve every settlement, and our fee is earned only after a settlement is reached, you approve it, and at least one payment is made toward it.
Downsides of Debt Settlement
Your credit score will be affected. Debt settlement will have a negative impact on your credit score.
Your balances can grow before they settle. Late fees and interest can keep adding up until each account is settled.
Collections and lawsuits are possible. The companies you owe may keep trying to collect, and some may sue.
Not every company agrees to settle. Some may refuse.
There’s a fee. You pay a fee on top of what you pay the companies you owe.
Forgiven debt may be taxable. Any amount that’s forgiven may count as income. The IRS explains the rules and exceptions.
Not everyone finishes. Not all clients complete their program, and your results depend on making your plan payments as agreed.
Read more about the pros and cons of debt settlement.
What Is a Debt Management Plan?
A debt management plan (DMP) is a repayment plan set up through a credit counseling agency, usually a nonprofit. It’s built for unsecured debt (debt that isn’t backed by something like a house or car), mostly credit cards. You repay your full balance, but your creditors may agree to lower your interest rates or waive some fees.
How a DMP works
- Talk with a credit counselor. A counselor reviews your income, bills, and debts with you and helps you build a budget. The first session is often free or low-cost. Learn more about credit counseling.
- Enroll, if a DMP fits. If your counselor recommends a DMP and you decide to go ahead, you’ll choose which debts to include. You’ll usually need to close the credit cards on the plan.
- The agency reaches out to the companies you owe. It asks each one to lower your interest rate or waive some fees. Not every creditor will say yes.
- You make one monthly payment. You pay the agency once a month, and it pays each company on the plan. Most plans take three to five years, and when you make your last payment, the debts on the plan are paid in full.
What Is Debt Settlement?
Debt settlement is a way to deal with unsecured debt, like credit cards and personal loans, by negotiating with the companies you owe to try to get them to accept less than the full balance. Instead of lowering your interest rate, it focuses on what you pay back.
How debt settlement works with ClearOne Advantage
- Get a free debt analysis. A Certified Debt Specialist reviews your debts, income, and budget and shows you what your plan payment could be. Inquiring is free and won’t impact your credit.
- Build up savings. You make one monthly plan payment into a dedicated, FDIC-insured savings account in your name.
- We work with the companies you owe. Once there’s enough saved, ClearOne Advantage works directly with each company to try to settle the account for less than the full balance.
- You approve each settlement. Every settlement needs your approval before it’s paid. Payments to the company come from your dedicated account.
There are no upfront fees. Our fee is earned only after a settlement is reached, you approve it, and at least one payment is made toward it.
What debts can be settled?
Debt settlement works with unsecured debt, like credit cards and personal loans. Secured debts, like a mortgage or car loan, usually can’t be settled this way. To work with ClearOne Advantage, you’ll need at least $10,000 in unsecured debt.
Alternatives to Debt Management and Debt Settlement
If neither option feels right, here are other paths to consider.
Debt consolidation loan
A debt consolidation loan is a new loan from a bank, credit union, or online lender that pays off your other debts. You then repay the loan, ideally at a lower interest rate than your credit cards. You still owe the full balance, and you’ll usually need good credit to qualify for a rate low enough to help. Unlike a DMP, your credit cards stay open. See how it compares in debt consolidation loan vs. debt settlement.
Repaying on your own, with or without a counselor
Credit counseling doesn’t always lead to a debt management plan. Many people leave a counseling session with a budget and a payoff plan they follow on their own, without enrolling in a DMP. Two common ways to pay it down yourself:
- Debt snowball: Pay off your smallest balance first while making minimum payments on the rest, then move to the next smallest.
- Debt avalanche: Pay off your highest-interest balance first, then move to the next highest. This usually costs less in interest over time.
To see how counseling compares with settlement, read credit counseling vs. debt settlement.
Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy is a legal process that can discharge (wipe out) some debts. Depending on the type you file, you may have to give up some property or follow a court-approved repayment plan. It also stays on your credit report for 7-10 years, depending on the chapter you file. A bankruptcy attorney can explain whether it makes sense for you. See how it compares in bankruptcy vs. debt relief.
Contact ClearOne Advantage
If you are struggling financially and don't know which solution is best for you, then contact a ClearOne Advantage Certified Debt Specialist today at 888-335-0896. We'll explain your options based on your personal circumstances and get a free savings estimate to see how much each can save you!
FAQs
Debt settlement usually has a bigger effect on your credit. A DMP can lower your score at first because closing cards raises your credit utilization, but it usually affects your credit less than debt settlement or bankruptcy, according to Experian. Debt settlement will have a negative impact on your credit score.
You can leave a DMP at any time, since it’s voluntary. If you leave, the companies you owe will likely bring back your original interest rates and fees, and you’ll go back to paying each one yourself, according to InCharge Debt Solutions. Before you decide, talk with your counselor about what leaving would mean. A Certified Debt Specialist can review your debts and help you see whether debt settlement could work for you.
Yes. The two terms are used interchangeably. Either way, you make one monthly payment to a credit counseling agency, which pays the companies you owe. Learn more about debt management plans.
No. ClearOne Advantage is a debt settlement company, not a credit counseling agency. If you’re comparing options, a Certified Debt Specialist can review your debts and budget and help you see whether debt settlement could work for you.
With a DMP, you still repay your full balance, usually over three to five years, and you’ll typically need to close the cards on the plan. Debt settlement may let you pay back less than you owe, but it has a negative impact on your credit score and other risks, like collection efforts, possible lawsuits, and taxes on forgiven debt. Which downsides matter more depends on whether you can afford to repay in full.
A debt consolidation loan is a new loan from a bank, credit union, or online lender that pays off your other debts, and you then repay the loan. A DMP isn’t a loan. You make one monthly payment to a credit counseling agency, which pays the companies you owe, and those companies may lower your interest rates. With both, you repay the full balance.





